Hilary Duff, 21, was recently spotted outside an NYC restaurant, with Joel Madden, 29. The two started dating in 2004, and broke up a few years later.
Hilary is dating Mike Comrie, right now. Joel is with Nicole Richie, and their daughter , Harlow. Why were these two spotted together, no one knows.
A rep for Hilary says that "they still are friends. Hilary knows what's going on with Joel , Nicole , and Harlow. She just wanted to have a nice little get-together with him, that's all. There's no problem."
"Nothing is going on, " says a rep for Joel Madden. We'll see!